Back to the MAIN PAGE

News / Archives / Press Releases Visit our On-Line Store DVDown Under Reviews
DVD Release Dates Upcoming DVD Sliicks & Screen  Shots DVDown Under SITE MAP

Visit DVD Station - OUR On-Line store
DVD Review
Patch Adams : Collector's Ed'n
Reviewed by Cassandra Nunn


  

Screen Format 2.35:1 16:9 Enhanced
Audio Tracks DD5.0 English
DD2.0 Commentary
Subtitles English
Region Code  2/4
Chapters 18
Disc Format RSDL - layer change at 53:51
Running Time 110  minutes
Features Theatrical Trailer
Outakes
Director's Commentary
Documentary
Animated Menus
Production Notes
Cast and Crew Biographies
Classification M 15+ (Adult Themes)

 

While the cover and the previews suggest otherwise this is not a comedy by any means. It is a heartfelt drama, which will touch everyone. Patch Adams is another incredible true story and from all accounts the bulk of the movie is actually a true story.

Hunter (Patch) Adams is a self admitted suicidal patient in a Mental hospital who discovers his worth in life when he helps a fellow patient overcome his fear of squirrels. He meets many amazing people in the hospital and touches the lives of them all including a patient suffering from genius syndrome who teaches Patch to look beyond what he sees.

After finding his talent with helping people Patch decides he is destined for a career in medicine. However, it is his tactics in health care which land him in some hot water. He practices a different kind of medicine for the medical genre of the 1970’s, believing that laughter is the best medicine, and that if you can treat a patient rather than the disease you can actually help improve the patients quality of life. After a rough term in college Patch decides to start his own free treatment centre for those who want his help or can’t afford it elsewhere.

Robin Williams has always been an outstanding actor slipping into some unusual roles and playing them all perfectly. Patch Adams is no exception. Monica potter as Carine is also convincing although not focused on so much as a main character. Other notable performances from Phillip Seymour Hoffman and Bob Gunton as the stickler Dean of Medicine.


So How Does This Transfer Hold Up??
The transfer quality is flawless, well at least I couldn’t find any flaws. There has been some mention of some slight strobing during a scene with Patch and Carine in the park at night but I certainly didn’t pick it up. The transfer is sharp and clear and the occasional loss of focus is certainly not noticeable. Colours are nicely saturated and not overdone; very fitting for a period film. As mentioned in the Directors commentary the colours in the mental hospital have been changed to be a little brighter and not so depressing which fits the mood perfectly. The majority of the film is a nice warmly rendered colour scheme once it changes to the medical school. This DVD is also dual Layered with the movie been split over the 2 layers, the change was a touch annoying as on my DVD player the break occurred as the school Dean was talking and cut off part of his line. [Ed... i saw this to also and it was NOT the best place for a layer change..tisk tisk]

Sound formats include: English Dolby Digital 5.0, French Dolby Digital 5.0, Italian Dolby Digital 5.0, Spanish Dolby Digital 5.0, and the English Audio Commentary Dolby Digital 2.0 track. The English Dolby track and the Audio Commentary being the two I have listened to. Although being a dialogue based movie the audio is also exceptional. I could find no sync problems and the dialogue was clear and sharp.

Mark Shaiman has composed a graceful score which, while not memorable by any means is certainly fitting for the film and at times emotionally powerful. The lack of bass and striking surround effects is hardly noticeable, as you are constantly involved in the dialogue and intermittently the musical score.

As a collectors edition we are treated to some additional extra’s which make interesting viewing. The animated menus are great with the little butterfly animation catching your eye beautifully. The only criticism of the menus is that the highlighted options can be difficult to recognise as they are only selected by a little white circle around an icon for each choice.

The audio commentary although not usually one of my favourite extras is quite interesting. Tom Shadyac is very passionate about his films and this is evident in the commentary. It is interesting to learn that almost the entire film is actually true. Of course beefed up a little in area’s all is based on the life of Hunter Adams and has been compressed some what for the film to be able to just include the highlights of about 17 years of Patch’s life. It is also entertaining to hear about the antics of Robin Williams on the set and the other thought processes in the making of the film.

Another fabulous extra in the documentary "The medicinal Value of Laughter". Here you can listen to the real Hunter Adams discuss what has happened in his life and how the writing of the book about his life: "Gesundheit: Good Health Is a Laughing Matter" came to the making of the film. Also including little tid bits from the making of the film. Definitely a must see!

From listening to the audio commentary you get the impression from Shadyac that there are some wild outtakes and while the ones included on the dvd are funny they are quite short and I was expecting a few more. Nevermind, those which we do get, are great, and you can see why other actors love to work with Robin Williams.

Other extras include the Theatrical trailer, production notes and cast and crew biographies.

Overall I am most impressed with this release. I saw this film at the cinemas and it has touched me even more to see it again. Robin Williams is hilarious at times and heart wrenching at other times. It is difficult to find faults and I would have to say that my biggest criticism would be the portrayal of the school dean who is at times overbearing. Other than that I commend the performances of Monica Potter (Con Air) and Phillip Seymour Hoffman (Twister). I am also impressed with the amount of believability as a true story and to learn from the commentary and the documentary that almost the entire film is quite true.
Seen it or not? See it again!

PICTURE QUALITY   4.5/5 sharp and clear virtually flawless
SOUND QUALITY   4/5 moving although not memorable
FEATURES   4.5/5 very entertaining
OVERALL   4/5


Review Equipment
TV: GE 68cm (16:9 selectable)
DVD: Samsung DVD907 (via S-Video)
Receiver/Proc: Sansui A505 & Yamaha DSP-E390
Speakers:-
Fronts: Wharfdale Diamond R6 (on a pair of custom made stands you'd KILL for)
Centre: Venturi
Rears: Sony bookshelf

- reviewed 28th October 1999


blackbit.jpg (285 bytes)


      Copyright 1999 by DVDown Under......this site looks best at 1024x768, but will get by at 800x600
      We FORBID you from  using 640x480 - go buy yourself a new 17" monitor right now!!!
      Found a Problem on this site or are just plain lonely, then please email us, email us now downunder@dvd.wow.aust.com